KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter - KiXtart.org - official site

You are not logged in. [Log In] KiXtart.org website » Forums » KiXtart » Lounge » KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter

Page 3 of 9

3

Topic Options

#99251 - 2003-03-12 12:30 AM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Lonkero Lonkero KiX Master Guru Registered: 2001-06-05 Posts: 22346 Loc: OK	same here richard. well, I go out and will see if it's done by evening. if not, I'll come back tomorrow... _________________________ ! download KiXnet
Top

#99252 - 2003-03-12 12:32 AM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Lonkero Lonkero KiX Master Guru Registered: 2001-06-05 Posts: 22346 Loc: OK	ah btw. jens, as your script already opens the console on wkix32.exe without printing anything. damn, there should be something coming out saying how many times it has ran and how many times more to come. _________________________ ! download KiXnet
Top

#99253 - 2003-03-12 12:37 AM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Richard H. Richard H. Administrator Registered: 2000-01-24 Posts: 4946 Loc: Leatherhead, Surrey, UK	I got fed up with the blank screen so I stopped it and added some diagnostic messages to the main script. So far I've got this: code: Loop #1 @ 09:29:59 CD #1 @ 09:29:59 CD #2 @ 09:31:37 CD #3 @ 09:31:39 CD #4 @ 09:31:43 CD #5 @ 09:31:46 It is now 11:42 local time, so CD#5 has taken 2 over 2 hours and hasn't finished wherase the rest of them took no more than a few minutes. Hmmm. very odd. Best have another look at that code...
Top

#99254 - 2003-03-12 12:41 AM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Lonkero Lonkero KiX Master Guru Registered: 2001-06-05 Posts: 22346 Loc: OK	well, there is some cd that is a lot longer than the others. jens, I got my loops to 5. _________________________ ! download KiXnet
Top

#99255 - 2003-03-12 12:52 AM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Lonkero Lonkero KiX Master Guru Registered: 2001-06-05 Posts: 22346 Loc: OK	woah! what is this: quote: ; number of times the challenge will be executed ; in order to post your results, you must run it 100 times what is the use in this and w00t! wicked. if ones script runs the whole week, he has no change to improve his code while it takes all reserves from the machine... re checked your code... it could indeed be less than 100 without harming anybody... _________________________ ! download KiXnet
Top

#99256 - 2003-03-11 02:39 PM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Richard H. Richard H. Administrator Registered: 2000-01-24 Posts: 4946 Loc: Leatherhead, Surrey, UK	Urk!? I think I've found part of the problem that CD#5 is taking so long. From a debug message: quote: Disk #5 Iteration #4 GAP=1.52655665885959E-015 LIST=.... Now, I've got a line which should exit the routine when the gap is less than 0.0001, but this very small value doesn't seem to trigger it. Hmmm.
Top

#99257 - 2003-03-11 03:26 PM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Lonkero Lonkero KiX Master Guru Registered: 2001-06-05 Posts: 22346 Loc: OK	richard... lol. yeah, you can do it work faster, but isn't this golf? golf thus far has been about as little strokes as possible, not as quick as possible. jens, are the goals changed? I made the script run just once and my code had run about 2 hours when I left home. and I'm sure, I can't return results before the private coding phase is over. even though the code works, it's results can't be announced as it takes more than just one week to run the check script! _________________________ ! download KiXnet
Top

#99258 - 2003-03-11 03:47 PM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Richard H. Richard H. Administrator Registered: 2000-01-24 Posts: 4946 Loc: Leatherhead, Surrey, UK	The reason for the extra code to reduce the run time is that I have exactly the same problem you have. It will take too long to run at the moment. Once I am happy that the solutions are correct I can remove the time saving code to save bytes and get a better golf score, but until then I need to leave it in.
Top

#99259 - 2003-03-11 04:04 PM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Sealeopard Sealeopard KiX Master Registered: 2001-04-25 Posts: 11164 Loc: Boston, MA, USA	I have posted an updated KiXGolf package at http://people.bu.edu/jenmeyer/kixtart/kixgolf_cd.zip The change is that it now saves the results for each CD to both the screen and the results file. An example results file is part of the package. I also added some calculations that will display the time the script needed to run. I willnot show the start date/time, the end date/time and the duration as part of the scoring part. The goal of the KiXGolf tournament has not changed. It is still about optimizing for least keystrokes. The only reason I put the 'loop 100 times' into the code is to deter the use of a brute-force approach. Though the 'brute-force approach' is defimitely a valid one, I don't see it as a challenge to just create a couple of FOR loops. be creative! I already gave one hint for a potentially powerful algorithm for this type of problem. If eerybody wished, I could spell out the method(s) that could be used. However, you would still have to code it. So far, I've already seen one solution posted which fulfills the requirements, namely it produced a list of song indices for each CD with each CD having a total length of <45 and it did finish in time. And Patrick did't even use the fastest computer for this I would also recommend to run your tests with just one loop and/or just one CD. [ 11. March 2003, 16:12: Message edited by: sealeopard ] _________________________ There are two types of vessels, submarines and targets.
Top

#99260 - 2003-03-11 04:48 PM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
MightyR1 MightyR1 MM club member Registered: 1999-09-09 Posts: 1264 Loc: The Netherlands	Jens, Brute force will search for "Perfect"... Really nice to get the best score out of 1,267,650,600,228,229,401,496,703,205,376 possible solutions (CD12) I know which algorithm type your talking about, but can't determine the three methods of approach you mean. Others, Does anyone else have a clue what Jens is talking about??? _________________________ Greetz, Patrick Rutten - We'll either find a way or make one... - Knowledge is power; knowing how to find it is more powerful... - Problems don't exist; they are challenges...
Top

#99261 - 2003-03-11 04:48 PM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Lonkero Lonkero KiX Master Guru Registered: 2001-06-05 Posts: 22346 Loc: OK	jens, I did your recommendation but as you have so many songs, the calc takes still time. the increase in time is awesome as say 5 songs calc in 3-4 seconds. 6 songs takes already a approx minute. what comes to having a sorter with less than the media total. sure, I had such sorter and the code was sorter than current. also it's execution time was damn fast. but I think we have to disagree still with the goals. you accept code that does somewhat correct thing. I see patricks code as unacceptable as it does not calc the perfect values and as such is not acceptable. sure, I could do for each cd to include only 1 song and with your current ruling, that would also be acceptable some rules would be good. _________________________ ! download KiXnet
Top

#99262 - 2003-03-11 04:51 PM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
MightyR1 MightyR1 MM club member Registered: 1999-09-09 Posts: 1264 Loc: The Netherlands	Agreed, Am going for perfect too. Will use one loop though... _________________________ Greetz, Patrick Rutten - We'll either find a way or make one... - Knowledge is power; knowing how to find it is more powerful... - Problems don't exist; they are challenges...
Top

#99263 - 2003-03-11 04:59 PM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Richard H. Richard H. Administrator Registered: 2000-01-24 Posts: 4946 Loc: Leatherhead, Surrey, UK	quote: Others, Does anyone else have a clue what Jens is talking about??? Nope, haven't got a clue. Two nations separated by a common language
Top

#99264 - 2003-03-11 05:10 PM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Sealeopard Sealeopard KiX Master Registered: 2001-04-25 Posts: 11164 Loc: Boston, MA, USA	There are three (as I know of) methods to solve this problem: 1) Brute-force 2) Limited search 3) Monte-Carlo Method or a combination of the above. Limited Search: A limited search would start with one song (e.g. the longest one), then choose a second one. If the second one fits, you choose a third one, and so on... Monte-Carlo Method: This method create random permutations of songlists. It then checks each songlist whether it is below the length limit and chooses the best fit. A combination would be to e.g. first do a Monte-Carlo, then search the leftover songs for a potential better fit of one of the already used songs. One thing that couldbe used is a sorted list of entries. [ 11. March 2003, 17:50: Message edited by: sealeopard ] _________________________ There are two types of vessels, submarines and targets.
Top

#99265 - 2003-03-11 05:15 PM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Lonkero Lonkero KiX Master Guru Registered: 2001-06-05 Posts: 22346 Loc: OK	dunno. my monte-carlo takes up hours for one cd and if I use limited it is fast but it indeed is not even close to perfect. for using combined... mm, it could be little faster but also a lot longer. _________________________ ! download KiXnet
Top

#99266 - 2003-03-11 05:19 PM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Richard H. Richard H. Administrator Registered: 2000-01-24 Posts: 4946 Loc: Leatherhead, Surrey, UK	Ahh. Thanks for that. I'm taking option one, but limiting it to one loop and a little recursion to make it all a little more aesthetically pleasing. 5 minutes for disks 1-8, but disk 9 is really pushing the envelope, it's taken 15 minutes to get the gap down to 0.000299999999987977. Maybe I should set a higher limit for the gap - it might catch all the "perfect" solutions.
Top

#99267 - 2003-03-11 07:54 PM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
maciep maciep Korg Regular Registered: 2002-06-14 Posts: 947 Loc: Pittsburgh	quote: Average CD Length = 44.8012916666667 Average Gap = 0.198708333333334 Average Gap [%] = 0.441574074074075 KiXtart KiXtart Version = 4.20 KiXGolf Script = kixgolf_cd.kix Computer OS = Windows XP Professional CPU = Intel Pentium III Speed = 730 MHz Memory = 126 MB KiXGolf Scoring Engine Scoring Engine = 3.0.3 KiXtart Golf Score Tournament = KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter Processing Start = 2003/03/11 13:43:41.815 Processing End = 2003/03/11 13:48:23.832 Duration = 0000/00/00 00:04:42.017 # Loops = 1 # Processed CDs = 12 # Valid CDs = 12 # Optimized CDs = 5 KiXGolf Result = Valid CD Sorter (Room For Improvement) KiXGolf Score = 396 Thank you for participating in KiXtart Golf! formatnumber() keeps bombing out on me, so I just got rid of all occurences. Anyway, need to get all cd's optimized now. Then I'll worry about my golf score. _________________________ Eric
Top

#99268 - 2003-03-11 08:13 PM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Sealeopard Sealeopard KiX Master Registered: 2001-04-25 Posts: 11164 Loc: Boston, MA, USA	Wow! Five optimized CDs, not bad. _________________________ There are two types of vessels, submarines and targets.
Top

#99269 - 2003-03-11 08:25 PM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Lonkero Lonkero KiX Master Guru Registered: 2001-06-05 Posts: 22346 Loc: OK	heh. added one small if statement and the execution time of all 100 loops was just one minute still, no optimized CDs. _________________________ ! download KiXnet
Top

#99270 - 2003-03-11 09:35 PM Re: KiXtart Golf: CD Sorter
Lonkero Lonkero KiX Master Guru Registered: 2001-06-05 Posts: 22346 Loc: OK	jens, I must admit that I got mad to you for thing not so big. as we know, the full-scan of possibilities takes zillion hours time (like my UDF) there can be some reliefe. either degrease the media time or song count or even loosen up the rules, like we have done now. what is the time on cd to be accepted? 50% gap? _________________________ ! download KiXnet
Top

Page 3 of 9

3

Previous Topic

Previous Topic View All Topics

View All Topics

Index Next Topic

Next Topic

Moderator: Arend_, Allen, Jochen, Radimus, Glenn Barnas, ShaneEP, Ruud van Velsen, Mart

Hop to:

Shout Box

Who's Online

0 registered and 700 anonymous users online.

Newest Members

Timothy, Jojo67, MaikSimon, kvn317, kixtarts2025
17874 Registered Users

Generated in 0.102 seconds in which 0.051 seconds were spent on a total of 12 queries. Zlib compression enabled.

click tracking