As a simpler and more flexible mechanism, use a modulo hash. You can do it on just the first character if you want:
quote:
$sFileName="Badge_"+(Asc(LCase($sLogin)) mod 3)+".ini"
Using the names from your example gives:
quote:
BUGAYORC=Badge_2.ini
CHURCHMX=Badge_0.ini
DELACRJV=Badge_1.ini
If you want to spread across more files, just change the modulo number from 3 to the number of files you require.

If you don't get a decent spread - perhaps many logins use the same first letter - sum the ASCII values of the login and apply the modulo to that instead.