Kent,I just whipped this table up (literally) off the top of my head. This comparison was not based any documentation and was in no way throughly researched. It's just my gut feelings on things.
However, it may stimulate (heated) discussion and at the end of the day - provide us with a good comparision. All feedback and critizisms welcome !!!
Plus - I'm not too familiar with ScriptLogic either, so maybe Brian Styles can fill in some blanks ...
The rankings are 1 (first place) 2 (second place) and 3 (third place). In the case of a tie - both or all three are assigned first place. The lower the score, the better (more first places) 
The categories, their meanings, and the rankings are totally subjective and open to debate...
The fact that all three tied was not by design ... but it is interesting and I guess the moral here (so far) is that each product has it's strengths and weaknesses ... let's see what some of the other members feel about this ... please submit your own tables if you like ...
code:
RANKINGS:CATEGORY KIXTART WSH SCRIPTLOGIC
FUNCTIONALITY - LOGIN 1 2 1
FUNCTIONALITY - GENERIC 2 1 3
EXPANDABILITY 2 1 3
FLEXIBILTY 2 1 3
RELIABILITY 1 1 1
PORTABILITY 1 2 1
EASE OF USE 2 3 1
PERFORMANCE 3 2 1
SUPPORT 2 3 1
PRICE 1 1 2
TOTALS: 17 17 17
-Shawn
